O
San Antonio
← Community
Water Utilitiesdeclining community discussion

Guajolote Ranch MUD

San Antonio

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Opposed (14)

At a glance

Public comments
14
Last 30 days
0
Importance
77

Declining — less community discussion. 0 comments in the last 30 days.

Public comments (14)

OpposedKate Hall FeistFeb 5, 2026

Spoke on behalf of the Scenic Loop-Holotes Creek Alliance, urging council to deny the MUD due to sensitive karst geology and threats to the water supply.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 56:28 →
OpposedJane SamsFeb 5, 2026

Shared family history of owning land adjacent to the project and described how fast water moves through holy karst rock directly into wells.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 57:26 →
OpposedMark D'ArazioFeb 5, 2026

State Representative for House District 122 urged council to vote no, noting broad bipartisan legislative opposition and fiscal impacts on taxpayers.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:05:21 →
OpposedSteve LeeFeb 5, 2026

Highlighted findings from hydrogeologists Dr. Ronald Green and Dr. George Vinnie refuting SAWS claims and warning that effluent could reach aquifers in days.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:10:06 →
OpposedStuart BirnbaumFeb 5, 2026

Geoscientist and retired UTSA professor explained that dye-tracing studies show direct hydrologic communication between the Trinity and Edwards aquifers.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:19:53 →
OpposedRandy NewmanFeb 5, 2026

Chair of the Scenic Loop-Holotes Creek Alliance steering committee urged council to deny the MUD to protect regional water and maintain legal leverage.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:28:33 →
OpposedEmory BloomFeb 5, 2026

President of Scenic Loop-Holotes Creek Alliance thanked elected officials for their time and noted legislative efforts to study wastewater discharge.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:36:24 →
OpposedRachel HaynesFeb 5, 2026

Policy Director at Greater Edwards Aquifer Alliance urged council to deny the MUD, citing high density, environmental threats, and developer history.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:40:59 →
OpposedLouis VetterFeb 5, 2026

Spoke on behalf of the San Antonio Conservation Society against the MUD, emphasizing the critical importance of protecting waterways.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:45:31 →
OpposedPatricia SeidenbergerFeb 5, 2026

Urged council to deny the MUD to prevent wastewater dumping into the Edwards Aquifer and protect drinking water for 1.7 million people.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:45:50 →
OpposedGeorge RiceFeb 5, 2026

Groundwater hydrologist stated that common sense dictates discharging sewage effluent into a stream recharging drinking water is a bad idea.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:48:37 →
OpposedIsabel HerreraFeb 5, 2026

Highlighted regional water shortages and urged council to deny the MUD, noting that contaminated groundwater cannot be reversed.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:49:20 →
OpposedGary SchindelFeb 5, 2026

Independent karst hydrogeologist and former EAA chief technical officer detailed extensive dye-tracing and fault data showing rapid groundwater movement.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 1:53:10 →
OpposedRonald GreenFeb 5, 2026

Groundwater hydrologist and co-author of the 2020 SwRI study reiterated that mass effluent load will degrade water quality regardless of facility type.

City Council A Session - Feb 5, 2026 · 2:05:24 →